Oxford Health Plans LLC v. Sutter
- Justice Breyer
- Use whatever word you want. Manifest disregard, stick to the law. Now, suppose the arbitrator had said this, it doesn’t say how to do it. I see how you do it, you get out a magic 8-ball. Now, we would strike that down because that is not relevant. But he didn’t say magic 8-ball. He said class. And there are many class arbitrations. So it isn’t quite magic 8-ball. Now, you explain to me --
- Justice Scalia
- What’s a magic 8-ball? I don’t know what you are talking about.
- Justice Breyer
- A magic 8-ball is you have -- that’s a little thing, it’s the -- it’s a non-sportsman’s equivalent of throwing darts.
https://www.supremecourt.gov/oral_arguments/argument_transcripts/12-135.pdf