Oxford Health Plans LLC v. Sutter

Justice Breyer
Use whatever word you want. Manifest disregard, stick to the law. Now, suppose the arbitrator had said this, it doesn’t say how to do it. I see how you do it, you get out a magic 8-ball. Now, we would strike that down because that is not relevant. But he didn’t say magic 8-ball. He said class. And there are many class arbitrations. So it isn’t quite magic 8-ball. Now, you explain to me --
Justice Scalia
What’s a magic 8-ball? I don’t know what you are talking about.
Justice Breyer
A magic 8-ball is you have -- that’s a little thing, it’s the -- it’s a non-sportsman’s equivalent of throwing darts.
Oxford Health Plans LLC v. Sutter Source